Best Eyeliners
The best eyeliner begins with the kind of line you like drawing. Compare a waterproof liquid pen for a defined stroke with a retractable waterproof pencil for a different application feel; both have traceable product mentions in the archive.
Research-led selections, not hands-on test results. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
Compare the shortlist
The selection order follows this guide’s criteria. Mention counts describe the archive; they are not performance scores.
| Product | Format & finish | Who mentioned it |
|---|---|---|
 StilaStay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner | Liquid eyelinerDefined waterproof line | View all 4 mentions |
 ChanelStylo Yeux Waterproof: Long-Lasting Eyeliner | Retractable eyelinerWaterproof pencil line | View all 8 mentions |
Yumi
Débora Nascimento
Candice HuffineThe selections, with their sources
Stila
Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner
Start with a liquid liner if a crisp, defined stroke is the goal.
4 people mentioned this product in the archive
Selected historical mentions below. A formula-level mention does not establish a shade match or use of a later reformulation.
Stila’s original Stay All Day is a waterproof liquid liner. It is the line-definition option here for readers comparing a liquid stroke with a softer, blendable-looking pencil outline.
Before you choose. The original, Micro Tip, and dual-ended versions are distinct. Verify the tip and exact product name before ordering.
Chanel
Stylo Yeux Waterproof: Long-Lasting Eyeliner
Choose the retractable-pencil direction if you prefer that drawing format.
8 people mentioned this product in the archive
Selected historical mentions below. A formula-level mention does not establish a shade match or use of a later reformulation.
Creator tutorial or favorites
Chanel’s Stylo Yeux Waterproof is a retractable pencil with an integrated sharpener. It is the pencil-format alternative in this comparison when you prefer drawing close to the lashes over a liquid pen.
Before you choose. Matte and satin finishes vary by shade. Check the color’s finish and the manufacturer’s intended application areas.
How to choose
Choose the tool before the claim
A waterproof label does not tell you whether a pen or pencil will be easier for you to use. Decide which format gives you the most control, then compare the relevant wear and removal directions.
Color includes finish
Black, brown, metallic, matte, and satin options can create very different effects. Read the shade description as carefully as the formula name, especially when a product family includes multiple finishes.
Your questions, answered
Can I use every eyeliner on the waterline?
Check the exact manufacturer instructions. An eyeliner name alone does not establish every intended application area.
Does waterproof mean difficult to remove?
Use the removal method specified for the formula. A suitable remover is more useful than repeated rubbing.
How we chose
Glisserati’s selections combine the criteria explained in this guide with current manufacturer information and documented historical product mentions. We compare the product’s stated role, format, finish, and practical limitations. We have not performed a comparative hands-on test, and manufacturer performance claims are not our test results.
We count distinct people with linked mentions, not the number of times a product appears. Source links retain the recorded publisher, context, and commercial disclosures where known. A person’s mention is a discovery lead, not proof of suitability for a skin type, shade, age, or background. Named variants are kept separate; source links may describe an earlier formula or shade.
Our organization is responsible for these guides; no individual testing or expert-review byline is implied. Prices and availability are not tracked. Retailer links may earn a commission. Read our approach or send a correction.